CAN IT BE ASTHMA - Q&A to How does the Doctor Know?
How can the doctor tell it is asthma?
The main symptoms of asthma, notably wheezing, breathlessness, coughing and chest tightness, are common to a number of other conditions as well. There is currently no single test that can be used on everyone to confirm that asthma is present. When diagnosing asthma the doctor may do one or more of the following to help confirm asthma is present.
  Examination at the Surgery
When the doctor examines you at the surgery he may not always find any signs that asthma is present. This is because asthma has such a variable nature as explained in the page What is Asthma? You may be wheezy and breathless in the night but fine by the time you visit the surgery the next day! This is why asthma can be missed as there may be no sign at all of any problem when you visit your doctor.
  Peak Flow Measurement
Your doctor may ask you to blow down a peak flow meter. This instrument measures how fast you can blow air out of your lungs. If this peak flow reading is low compared to your predicted peak flow, he may give you some reliever medication. The doctor will then get you to repeat your peak flow 15-20 minutes later. If it has improved by 15% or more over the original reading you may have asthma. This is called a reversibility test. This test cannot be performed by everyone. Children of 5 and under are generally too young to use a meter reliably and some adults cannot master the technique either. You can find out more about peak flow in Understanding Peak Flow.
  Spirometry
Some doctors have a spirometer which is an instrument similar to a peak flow meter. It also measures how fast you can blow out but gives additional information compared to the peak flow meter. It can sometimes be useful in people who do not show an improvement in their peak flow of 15% or more following a reversibility test carried out using a peak flow meter as outlined above.
  Taking a History
This can play a key part in diagnosing asthma. Your doctor will ask a number of questions. You are more likely to have asthma if:
(a) You have close relatives such as parents or brothers or sisters with asthma or who are atopic (have a tendency to be allergic).
(b) You are atopic (which means you have an allergic constitution). Other atopic conditions are hay fever and eczema.
(c) Your symptoms tend to come and go and are not present all the time.
(d) Your symptoms are brought on by exercise.
(e) Your symptoms are brought on by one or more common trigger factors.
(f) Your asthma is worse at night and in the early morning, then starts to improve by the middle of the day.
  Monitoring Your Condition at Home
If your doctor suspects asthma, s/he may get you to monitor your condition at home. This can confirm the diagnosis of asthma. Monitoring usually involves a combination of peak flow readings, symptoms experienced and triggers encountered on a daily basis over a period of two to three weeks.You can use the Asthma Assistant Application to make these recordings. Go to the sub-topic Getting to Know Your Asthma for more information on home monitoring.
  Trial of Medication
Sometimes the only way to conclude that asthma is the problem is to try the patient on one of the medications for asthma. This is particularly true in young children or some adults who cannot use a peak flow meter. If the medication works and there is an improvement in symptoms this can mean asthma.

What other conditions can seem like asthma?
There are a number of other conditions which can seem like asthma. In children these include the viral infection bronchiolitis, and cystic fibrosis. In adults, heart problems, colds and chest infections can have similar symptoms to those experienced in asthma.
Topic "Can it be Asthma?" Updated 14th August 2003  
Asthma Assistant Self Management Web Site - www.asthmaassistant.com
Copyright 1999-2003 © Polisa Health Limited